Ida Tarbell: Writer and Journalist Who Exposed the Standard Oil Company

| | February 29, 2024

Ida M. Tarbell, a key figure in the Progressive Era, gained fame through her investigative journalism in McClure’s Magazine, targeting monopolistic practices and the negative impacts of industrialization. Before her notable work on Standard Oil’s unethical practices, she was acclaimed for her serialized biography of Abraham Lincoln in 1895, showcasing her reformist spirit by highlighting the challenges of the time through Lincoln’s story.

Early Life

Ida Tarbell’s early years were deeply rooted in the burgeoning oil industry of Pennsylvania, where she was born in 1857, amidst the thriving chaos of capitalism that defined the era. Her birthplace, nestled in the oil-rich terrains near Oil Creek, Pennsylvania, was a frontier of industrial ambition. Her father, embodying the spirit of the time, was an innovator and an “ardent Republican” who contributed to the local economy by inventing a storage tank for the crude oil that was being extracted in copious amounts from the surrounding hills. This invention marked the Tarbell family’s initial prosperity and integration into the economic fabric of the region.

However, this period of industrial boom was not without its challenges. The Tarbell family, like many independent oil producers, faced dire adversity when John D. Rockefeller’s Standard Oil Company began to consolidate power over the oil industry, ultimately leading to the financial ruin of many small businessmen, including Tarbell’s father. This personal encounter with Rockefeller’s ruthless business tactics would later fuel Ida Tarbell’s investigative journalism against his monopoly.

READ MORE: John Rockefeller: Early Life, Family, Philanthropy, and More!

During her formative years in the early 1860s, the American Civil War raged, a conflict that Ida, although young, was conscious of. She and her brother engaged with the war’s developments through illustrations and reports in Harper’s Weekly and Harper’s Monthly, lying “heels in the air” on the floor of their home, their young minds absorbing the tumult of the nation. This early exposure to national events through the media was a precursor to her later career in journalism.

Tarbell’s earliest poignant memory of national significance was the assassination of President Abraham Lincoln in 1865. The tragic news, which caused her mother to rush into their home “sobbing as if her heart would break,” left a lasting impression on young Ida. The mourning that enveloped her household and indeed, the entire North, with homes draped in black, underscored the gravity of the event. This moment of national tragedy highlighted for Tarbell the existence of a world beyond the hills that encircled her childhood home, suggesting the interconnectedness of national events and personal life.

Ida Tarbell’s upbringing was thus marked by a unique blend of local industry involvement, personal adversity due to economic shifts, early engagement with national issues, and a significant historical event that shaped her perception of American society. These experiences ingrained in her a keen awareness of the broader forces at play beyond her immediate environment, laying the groundwork for her eventual path as a pioneering journalist and muckraker who would challenge the very titans of industry that impacted her early life.

Education

Ida Tarbell’s educational journey reflects her intellectual curiosity and determination to break through the gender barriers of her time. After her early exposure to the complexities of the oil industry and the broader socio-political landscape of post-Civil War America, Tarbell pursued higher education with vigor, a path less trodden by women in the late 19th century.

She began her formal education in the local schools of Pennsylvania, where her aptitude for learning quickly became evident. Recognizing the importance of education, Tarbell’s family supported her academic aspirations despite the prevailing gender norms that often limited women’s roles to domestic spheres.

In 1876, Tarbell took a significant step towards realizing her academic and professional aspirations by enrolling at Allegheny College in Meadville, Pennsylvania. She was one of the few women to attend college at that time, marking her as a pioneer for women’s higher education. At Allegheny, Tarbell excelled in her studies, immersing herself in a broad curriculum that included biology, which she initially thought would be her career path, along with other subjects that honed her critical thinking and writing skills. These skills would later become the foundation of her career.

Graduating in 1880, Tarbell was among the first women to receive a degree from Allegheny College, an achievement that underscored her resilience and dedication to breaking through societal limitations. Her academic journey did not just equip her with knowledge; it instilled in her a belief in the power of education to transcend gender barriers and a conviction in the role of women as equal participants in intellectual and public life.

Writing Career and Journalism

Tarbell began her work as a historian in France. After graduating from Allegheny College in Meadville, Pennsylvania, in 1880, Tarbell worked as a teacher for two years and then as assistant editor on the Chautauquan for eight years. Finally, she decided to go to France where she planned to support herself by writing for American syndicates and to make her name as a historian of the French Revolution.

Chautauquan and McClure

In 1892, Ida Tarbell’s article on Paris attracted S.S. McClure, leading to her important role at McClure’s Magazine, where she would later expose the Standard Oil Company. Initially, McClure focused on enlightening content, engaging Tarbell for a Napoleon biography and then a groundbreaking series on Abraham Lincoln. Despite the existence of comprehensive works by William Herndon, John G. Nicolay, and John Hay, McClure saw untapped potential in Lincoln’s story, instructing Tarbell to gather fresh insights, which took her from Kentucky courthouses to personal interviews, amassing a rich trove of material. This endeavor, blending rigorous research with a focus on Lincoln’s formative years in the American frontier, not only redefined Lincoln’s historiography but also honed Tarbell’s investigative skills.

Writing Articles about Rockefeller and Exposing the Standard Oil Company

Ida Minerva Tarbell notably exposed the Standard Oil Company’s monopolistic practices. Her motivation stemmed from witnessing the impact of rapid industrialization and the rise of monopolies, which echoed the societal concerns she explored through her work on Abraham Lincoln. Tarbell’s interest in Lincoln, as she expressed to Jesse Weik, never waned despite her shift to investigating Standard Oil in 1902. She believed in holding onto Lincoln’s legacy as a guiding principle, paralleling her continued exploration of his life with her groundbreaking series on Standard Oil.

Tarbell’s exposure of Standard Oil and its founder, John D. Rockefeller, was driven by a deep-seated belief in ethical business practices and the democratic process, values she found epitomized in Lincoln’s leadership. In her series, Tarbell detailed Rockefeller’s aggressive tactics to consolidate power within the oil industry, effectively dismantling the competition, including her father’s business. This personal connection underscored her work, providing a unique perspective on the consequences of unchecked corporate power.

Her writings went beyond mere criticism; they illustrated the complexities of monopoly power and its ramifications on democracy and societal welfare. Tarbell argued that the practices of Standard Oil and similar corporations represented a departure from the democratic ideals and ethical standards that Lincoln championed. Through her meticulous research and compelling narrative, she not only highlighted the predatory strategies of Standard Oil but also underscored the importance of accountability and reform in preserving democratic values.

Tarbell’s work on Rockefeller and Standard Oil was characterized by an unwavering commitment to factual accuracy and a deep concern for the public interest. She sought to educate her readers about the dangers posed by monopolies, advocating for legislative and societal changes to address these challenges. Her efforts contributed significantly to the antitrust movement, leading to greater scrutiny of corporate practices and the eventual breakup of Standard Oil.

Other Works

Beyond her pioneering, Ida Tarbell’s oeuvre encompasses a diverse range of writings that highlight her versatile literary talent. Her portfolio includes not only groundbreaking exposes but also historical biographies, essays, and an insightful autobiography. These works collectively showcase her depth of knowledge, her narrative prowess, and her unwavering commitment to shedding light on complex subjects with clarity and precision. Tarbell’s literary legacy is a testament to her role not just as a muckraker but as a profound thinker and writer whose contributions have significantly enriched American literature and journalism.

All in the Day’s Work

In “All in the Day’s Work,” Ida Tarbell provides a riveting account of her journey through the realms of journalism and history writing. This autobiography is more than a personal narrative; it serves as a lens through which the evolution of American journalism and the role of women in the field can be discerned. Tarbell’s reflections on her experiences, from her early life in Pennsylvania amidst the oil boom to her encounters with the titans of industry and her groundbreaking investigative work, offer a rare glimpse into the ethos of an era. The book delves into the intricacies of her investigative process, the ethical considerations she grappled with, and her unwavering dedication to the truth. Through her story, readers gain an understanding of the perseverance and integrity required to challenge societal norms and contribute meaningfully to the public discourse.

Retiring to Easton

Upon concluding her dynamic career, Ida Tarbell settled in Easton, Connecticut, a setting that reflected her transition from the fast-paced world of journalism to a life of reflection, writing, and community involvement. Easton became not just a place of retirement but a base from which Tarbell continued to influence the world of journalism and public discourse. Even in her retirement, she maintained an active role in advocating for journalistic integrity and continued her literary endeavors, contributing articles and essays on various subjects of public interest. Her home in Easton became a hub for intellectual discussion, where Tarbell nurtured the aspirations of emerging journalists, sharing insights from her illustrious career and emphasizing the importance of diligence, ethics, and the pursuit of truth in journalism.

Death and Legacy

Ida Tarbell passed away on January 6, 1944, at the age of 86. Her legacy as a pioneering journalist and muckraker endures, highlighted by her fearless exposé of the Standard Oil Company and her profound impact on the field of journalism. Tarbell’s work not only contributed to significant reforms in business practices and antitrust laws but also paved the way for future generations of journalists. Her dedication to uncovering the truth and holding power to account remains a benchmark for investigative reporting, inspiring journalists to pursue stories that matter with rigor and integrity.

Ida Tarbell: Pioneer of Investigative Journalism

Her contributions set a high bar for integrity and diligence in journalism, inspiring future generations to pursue truth and accountability. Tarbell not only broke ground for women in a male-dominated field but also championed the power of journalism as a force for democracy and justice, making her an enduring figure in the annals of American history.

How to Cite this Article

There are three different ways you can cite this article.

1. To cite this article in an academic-style article or paper, use:

James Hardy, "Ida Tarbell: Writer and Journalist Who Exposed the Standard Oil Company", History Cooperative, September 23, 2009, https://historycooperative.org/ida-tarbell-progressive-look-at-lincoln/. Accessed May 18, 2024

2. To link to this article in the text of an online publication, please use this URL:

https://historycooperative.org/ida-tarbell-progressive-look-at-lincoln/

3. If your web page requires an HTML link, please insert this code:

<a href="https://historycooperative.org/ida-tarbell-progressive-look-at-lincoln/">Ida Tarbell: Writer and Journalist Who Exposed the Standard Oil Company</a>

Leave a Comment

Share
Tweet
Reddit
Pin
Email