Elagabalus: The Most Eccentric Roman Emperor

Elagabalus, often remembered as the most eccentric Roman Emperor, ascended to the throne in a time of great upheaval. Born into a lineage of power and religious significance, his reign was marked by unprecedented acts that challenged Roman societal norms and traditions. From his religious reforms centered around the Syrian sun god El-Gabal to his scandalous personal life, Elagabalus’ actions left an indelible mark on Roman history.

Early Life and Rise to Power

Elagabalus, born Varius Avitus Bassianus in AD 203 or 204 in Emesa, Syria, was nestled into a lineage steeped in political and religious significance. As the son of Sextus Varius Marcellus, a Syrian who ascended to senatorial rank under Emperor Caracalla, and Julia Soaemias, Elagabalus’ connections were formidable. His maternal lineage was particularly distinguished: his grandmother, Julia Maesa, was the widow of consul Julius Avitus and sister to Julia Domna—empress and mother to emperors Geta and Caracalla. This heritage bestowed upon Elagabalus not only a noble standing but also the sacred office of high priest to the Syrian sun god, El-Gabal.

READ MORE: Sun Gods: Ancient Solar Deities From Around the World

The path to the throne was intricately woven by his grandmother Julia Maesa’s ambitions and the political machinations of the time. Blaming Emperor Macrinus for her sister Julia Domna’s demise, Maesa sought vengeance and a return to power. Capitalizing on Macrinus’ dwindling support, partly due to his unpopular peace treaty with the Parthians, Maesa and Soaemias propagated the claim that Elagabalus was Caracalla’s son, thereby securing the loyalty of the army, which still revered Caracalla’s memory.

READ MORE: The Roman Army

Central to their conspiracy was Gannys, a figure shrouded in mystery, who is variously described as a eunuch in Maesa’s service or possibly Soaemias’ lover. He was instrumental in orchestrating the plot to dethrone Macrinus, demonstrating the intricate web of loyalty and ambition that surrounded Elagabalus’ ascent.

Becoming an Emperor

In the shadowy hours preceding dawn on May 15, AD 218, Julia Maesa orchestrated a crucial moment in Roman history. Her grandson, Elagabalus, a mere fourteen years of age, was clandestinely escorted to the camp of Legio III Gallica at Raphaneae. As dawn broke on May 16, AD 218, he was unveiled to the legionnaires by their commander, Publius Valerius Comazon. Thanks to Julia Maesa’s considerable wealth, the troops had been swayed by a generous bribe, leading to Elagabalus being proclaimed emperor. Adopting the name Marcus Aurelius Antoninus, he was destined to be immortalized as ‘Elagabalus’, a nod to his deity.

The ascension of Elagabalus marked a turning point, with Gannys, a figure previously shrouded in mystery, emerging as the leader of the forces that would march against the reigning Emperor Macrinus. Their army swelled as defectors from Macrinus’ ranks joined their cause. The culminating clash near Antioch on June 8, AD 218, saw Gannys’ triumph, leading to Macrinus’ execution and Elagabalus’ uncontested claim to the empire.

READ MORE: The Roman Empire and Roman Emperors in Order: The Complete List from Caesar to the Fall of Rome

The Senate’s subsequent recognition of Elagabalus as emperor, affirming his fabricated lineage as Caracalla’s son and deifying Caracalla posthumously, underscored the political acumen of Julia Maesa and her daughter, Julia Soaemias. Their elevation to Augustae underscored the true locus of power within the empire.

However, Gannys’ prominence was short-lived. Initially poised for elevation, possibly through marriage to Julia Soaemias, his execution underscored the volatile nature of court politics. Even before reaching Rome, the empire’s loyalty was tested when the very troops who had proclaimed Elagabalus emperor revolted, albeit the uprising was swiftly quelled.

Rome under Elagabalus

The arrival of the new emperor and his two empresses at Rome in the autumn of AD 219 left the entire capital aghast. Among his imperial entourage Elagabalus had brought with him many low-born Syrians, who were now granted positions in high office.

Foremost among these Syrians was the very commander who had proclaimed Elagabalus emperor at Raphaneae, Publius Valerius Comazon. He was given the post of Praetorian prefect (and later city prefect of Rome) and became the most influential figure in government, aside from Julia Maesa.

But the greatest shock by far to the Romans came when they learnt that Elagabalus had in fact brought the ‘Black Stone’ with him from Emesa. This stone was in fact the most holy object of the cult of the Syrian god El-Gabal and had always resided in its temple at Emesa. With it coming to Rome it was made obvious to everyone that the new emperor intended to continue his duties as a priest of El-Gabal while residing at Rome. This was unimaginable.

Though in spite of such public outrage it did happen. A great temple was built on the Palatine hill, the so-called Elagaballium – better known as the ‘Temple of Elagabalus’, to hold the holy stone.

Having got off to such a bad start, the new emperor desperately needed to somehow improve his standing in the eyes of his Roman subjects. And so, already in AD 219 his grandmother organized a marriage between him and Julia Cornelia Paula, a lady of noble birth.

Any attempts to enhance Elagabalus’ standing with this marriage were however soon undone, by the ardor with which he undertook the worship of his god El-Gabal. Cattle and sheep were sacrificed in great numbers every day at dawn. High ranking Romans, even senators, had to attend these rites.

There are reports of severed human genitalia and small boys being sacrificed to the sun god. Although the truthfulness of these claims is very doubtful.

Achievements

Elagabalus’ arrival at Rome in the autumn of AD 219, accompanied by his two empresses and a retinue of Syrians, marked a significant cultural and religious shock for the Roman populace. His immediate entourage included many low-born Syrians, catapulted into high office, breaking with the tradition of privileging Roman nobility. Foremost among these was Publius Valerius Comazon, the commander who had declared Elagabalus emperor, now appointed as Praetorian Prefect and later as city prefect of Rome. Comazon’s influence in government was second only to Julia Maesa’s, highlighting the Syrian sway over the Roman administrative apparatus.

However, the most profound shock to Roman society was Elagabalus’ decision to bring the ‘Black Stone’ of Emesa to Rome. This act signified not just the physical relocation of a religious artifact but symbolized the imposition of a foreign deity’s worship at the heart of Roman spiritual life. The construction of the Elagaballium on the Palatine Hill to house this sacred stone underscored Elagabalus’ determination to elevate the cult of El-Gabal to preeminence within the Roman religious hierarchy.

READ MORE: Roman Religion

To mitigate the initial cultural and religious backlash, Elagabalus’ grandmother arranged his marriage to Julia Cornelia Paula, a woman of noble Roman birth. This move, intended to anchor Elagabalus within traditional Roman elite structures, was undermined by the emperor’s fervent devotion to El-Gabal. His daily sacrifices and the compulsory participation of Rome’s elite in these foreign rites further estranged him from the Roman populace and the Senate.

Reports of Elagabalus’ rituals involving human sacrifice, though likely exaggerated, fueled rumors that damaged his reputation further. These accounts, while reflecting Roman anxieties about foreign cults, underscore the extent to which Elagabalus was willing to challenge Roman religious norms.

Within the broader narrative of Elagabalus’ reign, this period of religious fervor and administrative overhaul illustrates a fundamental misunderstanding or disregard for the traditional values that underpinned Roman society. His actions not only alienated the Roman elite but also destabilized the delicate balance between the diverse religious practices within the empire. By prioritizing his devotion to El-Gabal over the established Roman pantheon, Elagabalus inadvertently catalyzed opposition that would culminate in his downfall.

READ MORE: Roman Gods and Goddesses: The Names and Stories of 29 Ancient Roman Gods

Elagabalus’ attempts to integrate El-Gabal into the Roman religious landscape were not merely acts of personal piety but were emblematic of a broader vision that challenged the very foundations of Roman identity. His reign, marked by these religious and cultural provocations, serves as a poignant example of the complexities of power, tradition, and identity in ancient Rome. Through his actions, Elagabalus not only reshaped the imperial administration but also tested the limits of religious tolerance and cultural assimilation in a society that prided itself on its adaptability and inclusiveness.

One of the Worst Roman Emperors?

Elagabalus’ reign is a study in the contrasts and conflicts between personal belief systems and societal norms, especially in the context of ancient Rome, a civilization known for its rigid hierarchies and value systems. His actions, particularly in the realms of religion and personal conduct, were seen not just as idiosyncratic but as direct challenges to the established order.

Elagabalus’ attempt to introduce and elevate the worship of the Syrian sun god, El-Gabal, above the traditional Roman pantheon was an affront to Roman religious and cultural sensibilities. This act was not merely a personal preference but a radical restructuring of Roman religious hierarchy, which threatened the existing balance of power and respect among the Roman gods and their priestly orders. Such a move was unprecedented and seen as an encroachment upon the religious freedoms and traditions of the Roman people.

The emperor’s reported sexual behaviors and marriages further compounded his notoriety. Marrying a Vestal Virgin, considered untouchable and sacred to Vesta, the goddess of the hearth, was a scandal of the highest order, violating one of Rome’s most sacred laws and traditions. His reported relationships and behaviors, which contemporary sources describe in lurid detail, were seen as perversions that undermined the moral and social fabric of Roman society.

Elagabalus’ political and administrative decisions were equally controversial. His elevation of unqualified favorites to high positions, based on personal loyalty or whims rather than merit, eroded the effectiveness and stability of Roman governance. This alienated the Roman elite, including the Senate, whose support was crucial for the legitimacy and smooth functioning of the emperor’s rule.

The legacy of Elagabalus is complex, marred by the biases and moral judgments of contemporary and later historians. While some aspects of his reign, like the promotion of religious pluralism and potentially challenging gender norms, might be viewed more sympathetically in modern contexts, it’s clear that his disregard for Roman traditions and norms was his undoing. His actions, seen as radical reforms or personal eccentricities, destabilized his rule and ultimately led to his assassination.

Elagabalus’ story is a vivid illustration of the tensions between personal authority and societal expectations. His reign demonstrates the limitations of imperial power when it is exercised without regard to the traditions and values of the governed. Despite the potential for religious innovation and the exploration of personal identity that his rule represents, Elagabalus is often remembered as a cautionary tale of excess, a ruler whose personal indulgences and religious fanaticism led to his downfall.

In the broader sweep of Roman history, Elagabalus exemplifies the challenges of managing a diverse empire with deeply entrenched traditions. His reign, though short-lived, prompts reflections on the role of the emperor not just as a political leader but as a cultural and religious figure whose actions could either bridge divides or deepen them. The controversies of his rule, from religious reforms to personal scandals, underscore the delicate balance between innovation and tradition, a balance that Elagabalus, for all his power, could not maintain.

Religious Fanaticism

Elagabalus’ religious fanaticism, particularly his devotion to the Syrian sun god El-Gabal (also known as Elagabal), was a key aspect of his reign and a primary source of conflict with the Roman establishment. The stone of Elagabalus, referred to as the Black Stone, was a sacred object in the cult of El-Gabal, emblematic of the deity itself. By transporting this revered object from Emesa (modern-day Homs, Syria) to Rome, Elagabalus not only physically brought his god into the heart of the empire but also symbolically asserted his intention to elevate El-Gabal above the traditional Roman pantheon.

This act was not merely a personal or religious statement but a radical political maneuver that challenged the religious and cultural foundations of the Roman state. Elagabalus attempted to integrate his deity into Roman religion by constructing a grand temple, the Elagabalium, on the Palatine Hill, and by organizing lavish ceremonies and sacrifices in honor of El-Gabal. These efforts to make El-Gabal the principal god of Rome were met with resistance and disdain from the Roman Senate and the populace, who viewed them as an affront to their traditions and religious practices.

Eccentricities and Scandals

Elagabalus’ reign was rife with behaviors and decisions that scandalized Roman society. His actions, often described as eccentric or outright scandalous, ranged from personal indulgences to public spectacles that defied Roman norms and values. Elagabalus’ purported habit of offering himself naked to passersby in the imperial palace and his role-playing as a prostitute subverted traditional Roman concepts of dignity and the imperial persona. These actions, coupled with his numerous and unconventional marriages—including to a Vestal Virgin, which was a grave religious transgression—only added to the public’s disdain.

The emperor’s religious practices, especially his daily sacrifices to El-Gabal, which were extravagantly opulent and out of step with Roman austerity, further alienated him from the populace. His attempt to marry the god El-Gabal to the Roman goddess Minerva, involving the transfer of Minerva’s ancient statue to the Elagabalium, was seen as an egregious attempt to syncretize Roman religious traditions with foreign cult practices, undermining the cultural and religious identity of Rome.

Elagabalus’ Complex Love Life

The discussions around Elagabalus’ gender identity and sexual orientation are among the most speculative yet fascinating aspects of his biography. Ancient sources, which must be read with caution due to their potential biases and the norms of their time, suggest that Elagabalus might have expressed a wish to live as a woman. Reports of his seeking surgery to alter his gender reflect a complexity of identity that resonates with contemporary discussions on gender fluidity, though applying modern terms and concepts to historical figures comes with inherent challenges.

Elagabalus’ relationships, particularly his marriage to Hierocles, a Carian slave, underscore his disregard for traditional gender roles and societal expectations. By referring to Hierocles as his husband and reportedly reveling in assuming a submissive role in their relationship, Elagabalus defied the rigid gender norms of his era. This relationship, along with his other marital and sexual liaisons, not only scandalized Roman society but also contributed to the perception of Elagabalus as an emperor who flagrantly violated the moral and social codes of his time.

READ MORE: Roman Slaves: Slavery in Ancient Rome

Political Instability

Elagabalus’ reign was marked by significant political instability, originating from his controversial rise to power through a military coup led by his grandmother, Julia Maesa. His rule was characterized by erratic governance, including frequent, arbitrary changes in administrative positions, which undermined government stability and eroded trust within the political elite.

He further alienated key Roman institutions, notably the Senate, by concentrating power among a close circle of confidants and family, damaging the traditional checks and balances of the Roman state. Elagabalus’ efforts to centralize religious power around the worship of El-Gabal, a foreign deity, challenged both the traditional priestly class and the broader societal norms, exacerbating tensions. His disregard for military traditions and the needs of the army weakened his support among the legions, contributing to a perception of weakness. These actions collectively destabilized his reign, leading to a volatile political climate that ultimately facilitated his downfall.

Downfall and Assassination

The downfall of Elagabalus was precipitated by his growing unpopularity, religious reforms, and the scandals surrounding his court. His grandmother, Julia Maesa, and her daughter Julia Avita Mamaea, seeing the emperor’s declining support, turned to Julia Maesa’s younger grandson, Alexander Severus, as a more suitable ruler. Elagabalus’ attempt to assassinate Alexander Severus failed, leading to his assassination by the Praetorian Guard on 11 March AD 222. His and his mother’s bodies were dragged through the streets of Rome and thrown into the Tiber, marking a violent end to his controversial reign.

Was Elaglabus misunderstood or truly mad? While his actions were undoubtedly shocking to Roman society, they might also reflect a young ruler’s attempt to navigate the immense pressures of imperial power while adhering to his religious convictions and personal identity. His reign challenges modern readers to consider the relative influence of cultural context, personal eccentricity, and political strategy in evaluating historical figures.

A Clash of Divinity and Decadence: The Enigmatic Reign of Elagabalus

Elagabalus’ reign is marked by extreme religious reforms and personal scandals, highlighting the tensions between innovation and tradition in Roman society. His downfall underscores the risks of alienating the Roman elite and military, showcasing the fragility of power when societal norms are challenged.

How to Cite this Article

There are three different ways you can cite this article.

1. To cite this article in an academic-style article or paper, use:

James Hardy, "Elagabalus: The Most Eccentric Roman Emperor", History Cooperative, July 29, 2020, https://historycooperative.org/roman-emperor-elagabalus/. Accessed May 21, 2024

2. To link to this article in the text of an online publication, please use this URL:

https://historycooperative.org/roman-emperor-elagabalus/

3. If your web page requires an HTML link, please insert this code:

<a href="https://historycooperative.org/roman-emperor-elagabalus/">Elagabalus: The Most Eccentric Roman Emperor</a>

Leave a Comment

Share
Tweet
Reddit
Pin
Email