World War II was a time of profound horror but also showcased immense courage and ingenuity. Amidst the conflict’s moral complexities, both sides fought for their deeply held beliefs. The revelation of the Holocaust’s atrocities shocked many, including German civilians who were later confronted with the grim realities of their government’s actions. Despite these moral quandaries, the war produced notable figures like Erwin Rommel, a distinguished German general whose life and actions reflect the nuanced nature of heroism in wartime.
Table of Contents
Early Life and Military Career
Erwin Rommel was born in 1891 on November 5th. His father was in the German artillery division and his mother was a schoolteacher. Erwin decided to follow after his father and attended a military school where he would graduate as a lieutenant at the age of 18. From that point on, his service in the military was marked by war, starting with the First World War.
READ MORE: What Caused World War 1? Political, Imperialistic, and Nationalistic Factors
Service in World War I
Rommel was a sharp man and a strong leader. He didn’t particularly worry about following exact orders during his participation in the First World War and because of it, his initiative would often lead him to pull off surprising victories and overtake his enemies using his quick wit and ability to determine the best course of action. He focused heavily on tactics in order to win a fight, using speed and surprise to his advantage each time. This made him somewhat different from many of the other military leaders at the time, who more or less tried to utilize brute force in order to win conflicts. Rommel rapidly moved up in ranks, going from a platoon leader to becoming a first lieutenant, later on becoming a captain.
Perhaps one of the most famous exploits during the First World War was when Rommel led his own mountain battalion to strike against the Italian forces who were positioned on various mountain ranges. Rommel’s forces were about 150 men and with those forces, he was able to capture 9,000 enemy soldiers. Such a feat was incredible and came about when Rommel decided the best way to fight against the Italian infantry wasn’t a direct assault but rather by moving in the woods to reach them. Rather than give in to the urge to take shots whenever they could, Rommel ordered his men to hold fire and not give away their position as they moved indirectly toward the heavy concentration of Italian soldiers.
Each time, Rommel’s forces would arrive using the terrain to outflank the Italians, causing them to surrender without much of a fight. Rommel would repeat this tactic until eventually they had seized the necessary territory and had captured the entire enemy force in that area. He did this by using tactics instead of brute force. This would be a precursor to Rommel’s time in World War 2, as his ability to strategize and focus made him a brilliant opponent to deal with.
READ MORE: WW2 Timeline and Dates
The Second World War
In the Second World War, Rommel was a major general and led his men on the frontlines. Indeed, Rommel’s picture of being a good leader meant being as close to the action as possible and he was often directing battles on the frontlines, despite the obvious dangers that this would cause for him. He believed in discipline and strength, but more than anything, he believed that a commander must be an example in all things to his men and so he would push himself physically to have the strongest body and discipline necessary to inspire his people.
Desert Wars and Becoming a Desert Fox
The majority of Rommel’s operations in World War 2 took place in North Africa, where he fought alongside the Italians in the newly formed Afrika Korps. Fighting in the desert was a new experience for Rommel but he took to it rather quickly and built a doctrine of mobility that allowed for his forces to rapidly move against their enemy. Rommel’s offensives were relatively successful against the Allies due to his fast-moving plans and his intense drive.
Relationship with Adolf Hitler
Erwin Rommel’s relationship with Adolf Hitler and the Nazi High Command was complex and fraught with tension. Rommel, a man of principle, valued merit over rank and often clashed with his peers and superiors due to his disregard for the German military’s hierarchical favoritism. His insistence on autonomy and reluctance to follow orders without question put him at odds with the rigid command structure, including Hitler himself. Despite serving in the Nazi-led military, Rommel was not a party member and openly despised attempts to label him as a Nazi supporter, maintaining a stance focused on the welfare of Germany rather than ideological alignment.
READ MORE: Adolph Hitler: The Beer Hall Putsch
Rommel’s interactions with Hitler were marked by a mix of respect and growing disillusionment. Initially, their relationship was based on mutual respect for military prowess, but as the war progressed, Rommel became increasingly critical of Hitler’s leadership and strategic decisions, which he saw as disastrous for Germany. Rommel’s loyalty to his country and his sense of duty led him to oppose Hitler’s increasingly irrational directives, recognizing the futility of the war and the destruction it brought to Germany. This patriotism and love for his homeland ultimately positioned Rommel in a delicate balance between serving his country and challenging the very leadership that was leading it to ruin.
Erwin Rommel’s disillusionment with the Nazi regime and Adolf Hitler intensified towards the war’s end, leading to his involvement in the July 20th Plot aimed at deposing Hitler. Rommel advocated for arresting Hitler to face justice, diverging from the plot’s initial assassination plan, fearing that killing Hitler would martyr him. However, an airstrike injury sidelined Rommel, preventing his active participation in the plot, which ultimately failed. Rommel’s connection to the conspiracy posed a significant risk to his reputation and the safety of his family, as the Nazi leadership saw his popularity as a threat and labeled him a traitor.
Faced with accusations of treason, Rommel was coerced into taking his own life to protect his family from reprisal and preserve his honor. He was compelled to choose between a public trial that would endanger his family and suicide, opting for the latter to ensure their safety. After saying goodbye to his family, Rommel consumed a cyanide capsule provided by Nazi officials, dying shortly thereafter. The regime then covered up his death, attributing it to war injuries, and granted him a hero’s funeral, keeping the truth hidden until after the war’s conclusion.
Commander Erwin Rommel’s Achievements
Erwin Rommel, often dubbed the Desert Fox for his cunning and strategic prowess in the North African Campaign during World War II, stands out as a remarkable figure in military history for several reasons. His fame and enduring legacy are attributed to a combination of his innovative military tactics, leadership qualities, and a certain level of chivalry in warfare that distinguished him from many of his contemporaries.
Firstly, Rommel is renowned for his mastery of armored warfare and rapid maneuver tactics. His ability to execute blitzkrieg operations in the challenging terrain of North Africa demonstrated a profound understanding of modern warfare’s dynamics. Rommel’s tactics emphasized speed, surprise, and the use of the environment to his advantage, often outmaneuvering his opponents and achieving significant victories against numerically superior forces.
Secondly, Rommel’s leadership style was characterized by his visibility on the front lines and his personal involvement in the planning and execution of operations. He was known to lead from the front, sharing the risks with his men and thereby earning their respect and loyalty. This hands-on approach not only motivated his troops but also allowed him to make swift decisions based on the changing conditions of the battlefield.
Moreover, Rommel’s reputation for conducting warfare with honor contributed to his fame. He was respected by both his allies and enemies for his refusal to engage in the brutal tactics that were all too common during the war. Reports suggest that he treated prisoners of war with dignity and was opposed to the execution of commandos and Jewish soldiers, actions that were in direct contradiction to the orders from the Nazi high command.
Despite serving under the Nazi regime, Rommel’s personal integrity, professional competence, and the apolitical stance he maintained throughout his career have led to a complex legacy. He was involved in the anti-Hitler plot not out of political ambition but from a sense of duty and patriotism, seeing the removal of Hitler as a necessary step to save Germany from total ruin. This act of defiance, coupled with his subsequent forced suicide, casts him as a tragic figure caught between his loyalty to his country and his moral compass.
Rommel’s fame thus stems from his exceptional skills as a military commander, his innovative tactics, and his conduct during one of history’s darkest periods. His legacy is a testament to the respect he commanded from friends and foes alike, making him a figure of study and admiration long after the war ended.
Erwin Rommel: A German Hero?
Erwin Rommel is often celebrated as a German hero, a designation that invites scrutiny due to the complex moral landscape of World War II. Rommel was a figure who prioritized justice and merit, demonstrating conduct largely devoid of the atrocities committed by the regime he served. However, the fact that he fought for a side responsible for the Holocaust raises questions about the nature of heroism and complicity.
The extent of Rommel’s awareness of the regime’s genocidal actions remains a subject of debate, complicated by efforts to cleanse his legacy post-war. Despite these ambiguities, Rommel’s adherence to principles like bravery, honor, and justice amidst a conflict defined by its ethical breaches suggests a nuanced legacy. His story exemplifies the challenge of navigating personal integrity within a broader context of moral failure. Thus, while Rommel’s actions and character might earn him respect for his commitment to these values, his hero status is intertwined with the larger tragedy of the era he served.
Erwin Rommel: Between Valor and Virtue in World War II
Erwin Rommel, the Desert Fox, stands out in World War II history for his leadership in the German Army and tactical brilliance in the North African Campaign. Despite his service under the Nazi regime, Rommel’s opposition to Hitler and involvement in a plot against him showcase a complex legacy of patriotism and ethical conflict. His contributions to armored warfare and the respect he commanded from both allies and enemies underline a career that challenges simple definitions of heroism, reflecting the profound moral complexities faced by military figures in times of war.